This may sound a little obscure but it needs to be addressed since it keeps coming up. As political rhetoric gets more heated it has become popular to say that extreme right-wing thinking will lead to another holocaust. Jordan Peterson is desperately claiming that naive millennial Marxists must take responsibility for all of Stalin’s and Mao’s crimes. This confuses me:
- Leftists detest income inequality. They may even propose a swing toward a Centrally Planned Economy (Marxism) as a solution. It can be shown that this is a terrible idea. It cannot be said though that a democracy run by industrial workers (“All Power to the Soviets”) has anything to do with starving farmers in Ukraine or working millions to death in Siberian Gulags. Mao starved his people in order to hoard grain to sell to Russia to pay for nuclear bombs. Where is that in Das Capital?
- Fascism is a tough thing to define but it isn’t necessarily the logical extension of extreme conservative thinking. Even if it were we have a variety of 20th-century fascist examples – Spain and Italy. They never engaged in genocide. Neither deported their Jewish populations to Polish death camps. Mussolini and Franco were not nice to their enemies but as dictators, we kind of figured they wouldn’t be. The problem is that Hume and Burke never said dictators were the way to go. What has any of this got to do with conservatism?
- Analogously we often hear religious people say that Stalin’s and Hitler’s atheism drove them to murder. I guess there’s a sort of Guidebook for Nonbelievers that says they have no beliefs except that murder is OK. In the name of believing in nothing, they condemn their citizenry to death(?)… or if they had followed Jesus they would be pacificists like Gandhi. Not even close.
Find me one conservative thinker who is in favor of ethnic cleansing. Then find me a Marxist who wants to set up a new government and murder all the capitalists. Can we stop this nonsense of using 20th-century similes when they make no sense? We need to take the good parts from both sides – that’s impossible if we associate either ideology with genocide. Let’s just agree that totalitarianism is a bad idea and leave it there.
If Trump starts to act like a dictator or seems to be unwilling to leave the oval office then bring on the 20th-century parallels!