Smart Republicans vs. Stupid Democrats

Friends of mine from Arizona recently made a coherent argument to me as to why they are registered independents. When I lived there, I too was an independent. Their argument is: We are pro-choice, we believe in science over superstition and we don’t want to destroy Medicare … but the Democratic party candidate was an idiot. We met her and she was completely uninformed about the issues. In fact, some of her positions were crazy!  

I get it. Let’s stay in AZ for a minute. Jeff Flake sounds like a reasonable man. He has a new book out where he talks at length about how Repubs must work with Dems to pass good laws. He thinks Trump is a buffoon. He is in favor of “free” trade and more immigration. Many Dems would see this well-mannered man as a better Senator than the Democratic party alternative.

Jeff Flake wins and off he goes to Washington and … Does he vote as an independent thinker? Does he question the leadership and work with Dems to write new bills? Not even close. Flake votes with Trump and Mitch McConnell every time (97%).  Yes, I understand that there is a lot of party pressure on all politicians and there are of course many demanding donors but what about the views of the candidate? Their views may get them “primaried” but with regard to their performance in Washington –

They don’t matter.

This new partisan world has set up loyalty as mandatory and the only people who can veer off the path are the famous senior party leaders or independents. Frankly, the opinions and intelligence of your senator or congressman mean absolutely nothing. Your moronic Democratic member in the house will always vote for the ACA. Your Republican renaissance man will vote against expanding the debt ceiling if Ryan tells him to. Unless the world changes dramatically, there is no role for the informed voter to cross over party lines and vote for someone in the other party. Do you believe in climate change and evolution? If you do then you don’t have the luxury of picking the smart Republican candidate, unless you want Texas style school books where Intelligent Design is given equal time.

Every politician has become a silent player on a team – following orders. The only direction he can go is further to the right (if he is a Repub) or to the left to join Bernie (if he is a Dem). Reasonableness and intelligence that bring someone to the center are features to be stripped away by Rush Limbaugh or the Freedom Caucus. You can be a maverick but you’ll only last one term.

Studying candidates carefully – expecting them to vote rationally and independently is a way to empower the leadership of the other party.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *